Sidr vs Shikakai vs Reetha: Which Hair Wash Powder Suits Your Hair?

Sidr is the mildest of the three hair wash powders, shikakai sits in the middle and reetha cleans the most. Here is how they compare, and how to choose by your scalp and your lengths.

The short answer: Sidr is the mildest of the three, shikakai sits in the middle and reetha cleans the most. Choose sidr for a soft routine wash, shikakai for a balanced one, and reetha when your roots are oily or you oil your hair before washing.

Sidr, shikakai or reetha: which should you choose?

Choose by how oily your scalp gets and how dry your lengths are. All three are plants that contain natural saponins, which is what lets them clean. They differ in how strongly they do it. A scalp that is oily by the next day needs more cleansing than one that goes several days, and dry or curly lengths do better with less.

Plant powders vary a little from harvest to harvest, so read mild, middle and strong as a practical guide.

What do the three have in common?

All three are mixed with warm water into a thin wash, worked into wet hair at the scalp, left for a few minutes and rinsed out thoroughly. None of them lathers like a shampoo, and all of them are ground plant material, so a careful rinse matters more than it does with a liquid. Each needs a patch test before first use, and each should be kept out of the eyes.

Where they differ is in how much oil they shift, and that is what the choice comes down to.

The three powders at a glance

Here is how they compare, side by side.

Sidr Shikakai Reetha
Plant part Leaves Fruit pods Soapnut fruit
Cleansing strength Mildest Mild to moderate Strongest of the three
Foam Light, sometimes hardly any Light to moderate The most visible
Everyday scalp oil Good fit Good fit Good fit
After heavy oiling May struggle Better, but varies Usually the best fit
Dry or curly hair Good fit Good fit, used thin Use with care, well diluted
Wash feel Soft, with slip Soft, with slip Very clean, can feel squeaky
Near the eyes Keep out of eyes Keep out of eyes Stings sharply; take extra care
Best for A soft routine wash A balanced wash Oily roots and oiled hair

Choose sidr if…

You want the mildest wash of the three.

  • Your scalp is normal or only slightly oily.
  • Your lengths are dry, curly or tangle easily, and you want a soft wash feel.
  • Your hair is coloured with henna or indigo and you want a mild wash between colour days.
  • You have found reetha-based washes too strong.

How to use sidr powder for hair has the method, and the sidr page has more about the powder.

Choose shikakai if…

You want a balanced wash with a long tradition behind it.

  • Your scalp is normal to slightly oily.
  • You want a wash that is still mild but cleans a little more than sidr.
  • You like the classic three-powder wash of amla, reetha and shikakai.

There is more on the shikakai page and in the shikakai guide.

Choose reetha if…

You need more cleansing.

  • Your roots are oily again soon after washing.
  • You oil your hair before you wash it.
  • Milder powders leave your roots feeling greasy.

Reetha wash water stings sharply if it gets into the eyes, so keep your head tilted back and your eyes closed while you rinse. There is more on the reetha page.

Can you use them together?

Yes. They are often combined when sidr alone doesn't clean enough but you still want a plant wash. Sidr with shikakai gives a wash with a little more cleansing. Sidr with reetha is the strongest sidr wash. Shikakai with reetha is the long-established pair.

Using more than one cleanser doesn't mean leaving the wash on for longer. The amounts for each blend are in the Complete Mixing and Application Guide that comes with your pack.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is best for dry hair?

Sidr or shikakai, mixed thin and used mainly on the scalp, with a thorough rinse and conditioner on the lengths afterwards. Reetha is the one to cut back first if a wash leaves your hair feeling dry.

Which is best after heavy oiling?

Reetha. It is the strongest cleanser of the three. Hair that is saturated with oil may still need a second wash or a shampoo.

Which foams the most?

Reetha. Sidr and shikakai foam lightly, and sometimes hardly at all. Foam isn't a measure of how clean your scalp gets, so judge by how your roots feel after rinsing.

Which is best for henna- or indigo-coloured hair?

Sidr is the usual choice because it is the mildest. No wash can promise that colour won't fade at all. After indigo, wait at least 24 hours before you wash your hair with anything.

Can I use any of them every day?

None of them needs to be a daily wash. Sidr is used up to twice a week, and shikakai and reetha are adjusted to how oily your scalp gets.

Can these powders replace shampoo?

On many wash days, yes. A formulated shampoo is still the better tool for heavy styling build-up, for hair saturated with oil, or when you need a medicated shampoo. Using one when it suits doesn't mean the powders have failed.

Which is better, reetha or shikakai?

That depends on your scalp. Reetha vs shikakai compares the two in detail, and which Ayurvedic hair powder? covers the care powders as well.

Related reading

Guides Where to Buy Ayurvedic Hair Powders in the UK: What to Check Before You Buy Supermarkets, health shops, Asian grocers and online specialists don't stock the same kind of herbal powder... Guides Which Ayurvedic Hair Powder Should You Use? Amla vs Bhringraj vs Brahmi vs Reetha vs Shikakai Nine powders, and the difference between them is what job they do rather than which is strongest. Here is w... How-to How to Use Sidr Powder for Hair: The Wash, Step by Step A sidr wash takes about half an hour. Here is how much powder and water to use for your hair length, how lo... How-to Amla, Reetha, Shikakai and Bhringraj: The Four-Powder Hair Wash The classic four-powder wash, with the amounts and timings: 1 tablespoon each of amla, reetha, shikakai and... Myths Does Sidr Regrow Hair? What a Mild Wash Can and Can't Do Sidr is a mild hair wash that leaves hair soft and easier to comb, so less of it breaks. It has not been sh... Troubleshooting Reetha Side Effects: Dry Hair, Tangles, Eye Sting and How to Avoid Them Dryness, tangles, grit and eye sting are the usual reetha side effects, and nearly all of them come from a ...